112 Iowa L. Rev. 373 (2026)
 

DOWNLOAD PDF

Abstract

Iowa is one of the few states that requires indigent defendants to pay for their court-appointed counsel even when they are acquitted of all charges. This Note asserts that this practice entrenches low-income Iowans in poverty, undermines the presumption of innocence, and serves no legitimate policy goal. It further argues that imposing such fees violates due process by effectively punishing indigent defendants absent a conviction. Although monetary sanctions have expanded nationwide as states increasingly rely on fines and fees to fund their criminal justice systems, Iowa stands out for imposing some of the highest indigent defense fees in the country. These fees function as poverty penalties, imposing financial burdens on those who are too poor to pay. Moreover, Iowa recovers only a small percentage of the fees assessed, making the practice an ineffective revenue source and counterproductive to defendant accountability. This Note, therefore, contends that section 815.9(6) of the Iowa Code should be repealed and that existing debts assessed under its authority should be forgiven. Alternatively, it proposes targeted legislative amendments to protect acquitted indigent defendants and restore fairness and legitimacy to Iowa’s criminal justice system.

Published:
Sunday, November 15, 2026