112 Iowa L. Rev. Online 1 (2026)
 

DOWNLOAD PDF

Abstract

Pretrial diversion is a procedural alternative to traditional criminal prosecution where the prosecutor dismisses a low-level charge once the defendant successfully completes required programming. Diversion reduces the collateral consequences of a criminal record and serves to address mass incarceration through decarceration. Among the states that have codified pretrial diversion programs into law, there remains considerable variation in the degree of legislative control over eligibility requirements, program implementation, and recordkeeping. Although a small number of states require prosecutors to establish diversion programs under legislative guidance, most merely authorize prosecutors to create and implement programs as an exercise of prosecutorial discretion. Many states, including Iowa, have no diversion statute at all. This patchwork approach to pretrial diversion limits the collection of reliable data regarding program efficacy and allows diversion programs to operate with little accountability—exacerbating existing racial and socioeconomic disparities. Pretrial diversion programs are powerful tools capable of meaningful criminal justice reform if properly designed and measured. This Note argues that legislatures should enact pretrial diversion statutes that direct how programs are created, implemented, and evaluated, and presents a sample Iowa statute that can be adapted nationwide.

Published:
Monday, November 16, 2026