112 Iowa L. Rev. 137 (2026)
 

DOWNLOAD PDF

Abstract

Immigrants exist within networks of social relationships that shape their identities, inform their decision-making, and guide their behavior. Certain areas of substantive U.S. immigration law—the body of law governing who may enter or remain in the United States—acknowledge this social embeddedness by protecting or privileging valued social relationships. In contrast, many aspects of procedural immigration law—the set of rules governing how substantive immigration law is implemented and enforced—undermine or destroy those very relationships. The U.S. government’s practice of transferring immigrant detainees across multiple detention facilities and confining them in remote locations is a paradigmatic example of such destructive procedural immigration law in action.

This Article presents the first systematic empirical analysis of interfacility transfers and remote detention in the U.S. immigration detention system. Our findings show that over the past fifteen years, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has routinely relied on long-distance transfers crossing state lines and federal judicial circuits, and on confinement in remote locations. Some of these practices have sharply accelerated during the second Trump administration: Compared to the Biden administration, the share of detention stays with two or more transfers increased from 19% to 55%; intercircuit transfers into the Fifth Circuit—long regarded as among the least favorable jurisdictions for noncitizens—increased from 55% to 70% of all intercircuit transfers; and the share of individuals ever experiencing remote detention increased from 71% to 81%. We argue that procedural immigration law must take seriously the social embeddedness of immigrants, and that doing so requires strictly limiting and regulating the use of interfacility transfers and remote detention.

Published:
Sunday, November 15, 2026